Citizen. Speak. Amplify.

We have 10+ questions for the Wits student leadership

After negotiations between students and management broke down on Thursday, Wits University announced a postponement of Friday’s scheduled general assembly. Students expressed shock and disappointment at the postponement, but the future of the movement now requires decisive leadership.

According to management, students had presented the other stakeholders at the university with a new demand. “One of the latest demands of the protesting students is that Wits and all other universities should be shut down until the government agrees to free education,” the statement said. So, we have some questions for the student leadership.

1. How do you see protracted university shutdowns as resulting in free education? These shutdowns are a means to what end exactly?

2. Quoting from management’s statement on Friday morning again, “There has been no consensus from all constituencies and no agreement from the protesting students that the academic programme will continue on Monday.”

The university reopening is the only thing management wants, we all know this. Why are continued shutdowns strategically seen as more valuable than collective university endorsement?

3. Have you considered the effects of a protracted shutdown that annuls this academic year? We understand that sacrifices have to be made along the way. But have you weighed the costs? What happens to students on bursaries? What happens to students on NSFAS? What happens to students whose parents have paid their fees this year, amidst great difficulty? What about students who are just a couple of exams away from graduation? The matrics? What about the hospitals that depend on a fresh intake of interns? The schools that will need teachers?

4. Who exactly do you represent? Do you have the mandate from the masses? Have you made any efforts to engage the thousands of people who voted for the resumption of the academic programme?

5. Blade said that student leaders had agreed to his intervention when wearing their SAUS hats, and then threw him under the bus, when they returned to their constituencies. Among you are students who hold senior positions at SAUS, so what is your response to Blade?

6. Adam Habib has accused you, as protesting students, of orchestrating a “political spectacle”, at the expense of sincere engagement to resolve the current impasse. How do you respond to this?

7. Where are the womxn?

There are significant fractures in the student body at Wits, particularly across party political affiliations. SRC representatives, all of them PYA members, continue to be treated with suspicion, especially after their engagements with management and police. We know that you have elected six people across party divides to represent the movement, and have also outlawed party t-shirts in an effort to foster unity. But there continues to be suspicion of PYA affiliates, whom a certain faction believe will sell out the cause. At the same time, we’ve seen the return of Mcebo Dlamini and Vuyani Pambo – the latter of whom had declined a leadership position, and yet, he’s seen leading many a march the last few days.

8. When you speak to management, what exactly are your non-negotiables?

9. How is the goal of free education, with which – make no mistake – we also agree, achievable right now?

10. Why free education for all and not free education for the poor?

11. Indulge us on this one. Who are your handlers in the third force? 😜

Featured image by Dennis Dvornak
5 Comments
  1. Travis B says

    Well done for at last having the courage to put some tough questions to these brutal fascists, after sucking up to them and romanticising their selfish, destructive attempts at a revolution.

  2. Dom says

    Thank you Daily Vox. This is the first piece to show that you are thinking of the majority of students and not the ideological political wannabes, who will sacrifice other people’s rights on the altar of their own egos. It’s just a pity that you will not put the byline (name of the writer) on this piece. Are you fearful for the writer’s safety or a backlash from the demagogues? This is what has been the problem with this whole sorry saga and you have perpetuated this by naming and shaming those with opposing viewpoints or mocking the silent majority. We need people with courage to stand up for everyone’s rights.

  3. Levarkan Madurai says

    Hospitals can survive for now without a year of interns. The 2nd year interns will still be around. However, in 2019, due to the year of lost interns, there will be no community service doctors, and in a lot of places, they are the only doctors people will see. Expect many deaths to be swept under the rug and blamed on errors in the system.

    I just have a few other questions that need to be asked.

    1. What if a student fails? Will that student be allowed to repeat for free?
    2. What if a student decides that after a year, the course isn’t for him, and that students wants to switch courses. Can that student do it for free?
    3. Has the student collective actually drawn up a detailed list of demands, and at least shown some logic in this plan? Free education for all is such a blanket statement. Its a dangerous statement.

    1. Jackie Downs says

      Hospitals cannot survive without new interns for next year. the interns already are spread too thin there numbers will be halved next year.
      I like your other questions.

  4. Bruce Gorton says

    My questions for #feesmustfall

    1: Have you made an effort to understand why management feel they can’t do away with fees?

    2: Can you describe their opposing argument?

    3: How do you propose dealing with the objections raised in that argument?

    4: How does giving in to your demands benefit me, a non-university going South African?

    5: Your protests have, from the start, included intimidation of other students, damage to university property, and calls for racialist violence (EG: Kill all the whites,). Your movement includes people who threw their own faeces at fellow students and smeared it on computers at UKZN, do you think this behaviour makes us think you should be allowed on campus?

Leave A Reply

Your email address will not be published.