Citizen. Speak. Amplify.

#BlackMonday: Whither the political leadership?

That South Africa is a bitterly divided society is a trite observation, and those divisions must inevitably play out in how different groups interpret social ills that affect us all.

Black Monday was one such moment – hundreds of people across the country wore black and marched to protest farm murders. The march, which was supported by AfriForum, agricultural and business groups, as well as ordinary citizens, was sparked by the brutal murder of a farmer in the Western Cape during a robbery. Crime is a terrible problem in our country. However, many of the protest signs and comments made at various marches suggested another interpretation: that farm murders are in fact a targeted, political attack on whites. That they are evidence of “white genocide”.

There is no amount of proper statistical analysis that shows that farm murders are largely about theft, not racial animus, and that the attacks on white farmers are overwhelmed by the impact of crime on black people in townships and informal settlements whether in urban or rural spaces, that will change the tone and direction of this debate. People are simply talking past each other.

Whatever the intentions of the marchers, it cannot be wished away that for some people, this was an opportunity to bring out that old symbol of hatred and white supremacy, the flag of apartheid South Africa. The debate on the appropriateness of this symbol is not just long overdue – parliament should have long ago banished it from a society premised on non-racialism, non-sexism and freedom. It is truly the Nazi flag of South Africa, and we should be treating it the same way that the German people treat that symbol of hatred and white supremacy.

Instead of this bold leadership from the party of governance, the African National Congress (ANC), we got weak condemnations and inaction. That response is in keeping largely with the government’s tepid response to the specific and urgent safety needs of our rural communities.

In fact, none of the three biggest political parties provided much-needed political leadership on a day of bitter resentment. The ANC, Democratic Alliance and Economic Freedom Fighters failed to unite all South Africans around a proper understanding of crime and how to combat it. Each in their own way contributed to the ‘talking past each other’ problem.

Rural communities deserve protection regardless of race. This message should be received by any South African without any need for racist dog-whistling and a nostalgia for the ugly days of apartheid. It is our political parties who should be leading this conversation. On Black Monday, they did not.

Featured image by Nicolas Raymond
3 Comments
  1. Jon Low says

    Funny that in the first 20 years after the flag made its first official appearance in 1928, it was, in fact, the proud and honourable battle standard of the SADF who went off to fight the Nazis between 1939-1945. Apartheid only commenced in 1948.

    1. Dave says

      These cultural marxists don’t care about real history.

  2. David says

    Agree on the debate of banning the ‘old’ Flag it has no place in this incredible country, and truly spoiled what could perhaps have been, of itself, a uniting gathering, towards a common cause of ALL South African’s.

    All South African’s experiencing unacceptable crime levels – this was surely simply one sector of the population making a stand for that occurring directly within in THEIR ‘realm’, not to lessen any similar experiences within other sectors/realms of the population ?

    And yes a significant opportunity to unite missed by leaders….

Leave A Reply

Your email address will not be published.