Department of human settlements gets roasted in Parliament for its failures


In 2017, South Africa saw many communities mobilise to protest for affordable housing from the government. The people of Eldorado Park, Freedom Park, and Hout Bay are just some of the areas where poor and working-class citizens felt frustrated and sidelined by the slow rate of housing allocation.

The department of human settlements (DHS) presented its 2016/17 annual report to the National Council of Provinces (NCOP) social services committee in Parliament. The Daily Vox takes a look at the report and what emerged at the meeting on Tuesday, 28 November.

The department received an unqualified audit opinion, the best possible opinion the Auditor General can give. This means the DHS’s statements fairly represented its finances.

The department spent R30.5 billion, which is 99.6% of its total expenditure budget for the year. Most of it was spent on grants and transfer payments to public entities like the National Housing Finance Corporation. Underspending was mainly due to unfilled vacancies in the department.

Between 2014/15 and 2016/17, DHS completed 265 271 units, while 56 informal settlements were fully formalised and received full services like water and electricity.

It however failed to meet their targets on addressing the 800 000 title deed restoration backlog, upgrading houses in informal settlements, developing subsidy housing units, and creating affordable rental housing opportunities. It also hasn’t fully implemented its anti-fraud and corruption plan.

On the level of provinces, DHS reported that all of its settlement grants were transferred to municipalities. In term of meeting its targets, the Free State, Gauteng, Limpopo, and North West fell short and were listed as still “in ICU” while Mpumalanga showed progress.

The top performing municipalities in South Africa are eThekwini and Nelson Mandela Bay. The three big metros – Cape Town, Ekurhuleni, and Johannesburg – underspent on their human settlement development grants.

The committee also focussed on the fact that small cities were being sidelined by the national department. IFP MP Mntomuhle Khawula noted that despite KwaZulu-Natal having the second-largest population density after Gauteng, only one out of three metros received grants.

The committee called for the department to reconsider how it allocated grants. ANC MP Tsapane Mampuru said it should rather focus on population density than metros when allocating grants.

Lungelwa Zwane, ANC committee MP, said that it was unacceptable that some municipalities like Nelson Mandela Bay, Johannesburg, and Cape Town had underspent its funds. In the Parliamentary Monitoring Group’s minutes of the meeting, Zwane asked why the department wasn’t monitoring this.

Overall, the committee was not happy with the presentation, especially considering that both the minister Lindiwe Sisulu and deputy minister Zou Kota-Fredericks didn’t attend the meeting.


  1. comrades where builder of low cost housing -low income housing provide its own supplies plus possess its own essential equipment housing may be efficiently constructed nationwide at affordable cost. Problem is Rich of South Africa control building supplies trade plus have created numerous undue cost to inflate cost of supplies so that they receive huge profits on all building supplies they sell. As I had set forth in support of Dr. Nkosazana Dlamini Zuma ANC plus President of South Africa bid that as a contractor to government of South Africa for construction of low income housing I would form small companies to produce overwhelming majority of supplies I would need to build low income homes. There would be greater use of Earth Blocks plus modern plastics of various grades plus forms for windows, maybe roofs etc. We would build millions of quality low income homes in rural areas plus cities for a fraction of what it would cost under deceitful system builders plus suppliers of South Africa say it will cost. Without Dr. Nkosazana Dlamini Zuma I am free to move on to elsewhere in Africa. My efforts would be result of attempt to repay assistance provided to my group by Dr. DlaminiZuma while she was African Union Commission Chairperson. Very much sincere, Henry Author (people of books) Price Jr. aka Obediah Buntu IL-Khan aka Kankan aka Gue.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here