Citizen. Speak. Amplify.

It’s almost 2016 and we’re still having to explain why blackface is wrong

After the incident last year when two University of Pretoria students wore blackface to a party, one could assume we would all be clear on the fact that blackface is racist and shouldn’t be worn. Sadly, one Wits medical student still hadn’t gotten the memo. PONTSHO PILANE explains.

It seems to be the same script every time – a group of students decided to throw a party (this time it was themed Under the African Sky) and one of them thought dressing like a domestic worker while wearing blackface would be a good idea.

Wits blackface [screengrab via Facebook][name blacked out]

 

Medical student Shari Weinstein initially uploaded the pictures to Facebook but deleted them after her classmates called her out on condoning the racist actions of her friend.*

Winstein offered an apology saying that she had posted the pictures “in all innocence” and that “some of the pictures may have offended people”.

Shari Weinstein apology Wits blackface

Based on the wording, it seems she still doesn’t really understand why what she did was wrong. So, once again, here are three reasons why blackface is, and always will be, a no-no:

1. History actually matters
Melissa Steyn, professor of the Wits Centre for Diversity Studies, describes blackface as “a visual equivalent of a racist joke”. Blackface, started in American minstrels shows in which white people would perform in blackface, portraying black people as lazy and playing up perceptions of black people as sub-human for the sake of laughs.

2. It’s about humiliating black people
Blackface is based on the notion of making black people look inferior. It is a performance that often exaggerates certain features of black people, as when the UP students stuffed pillows into their pants.

3. Black lives are not a costume
It seems the go-to representation of black people by the students involved is always that of a domestic worker. (In the 2014 incident at UP, the students also dressed as domestic workers.) These university-going young adults are surely exposed to a variety of black people every day, including classmates and lecturers, yet they choose to impersonate domestic workers for laughs. It is clear that these students do not see black people beyond those in subservient roles.

In short, blackface is and will always be wrong. Do. Not. Do. It.

And while you’re at it, don’t post pictures of other people doing it among the happy snaps from your party. In fact if someone turns up at your party wearing blackface, tell them to get some perspective and go wash their face.

* A previous version of this story implied that more than one Wits med student was involved in the incident. This has been corrected.

5 Comments
  1. Andre says

    Is black face always wrong? I agree that in this case it could be considered racist/wrong at the very least distasteful. I’m white and one of my hero’s is Neil Degrasse Tyson, who is black, so if I go to a fancy dress party dressed up as Neil, including black face, would you consider that wrong or racist?

    1. The Daily Vox Team
      The Daily Vox Team says

      Yes, that would be both racist and lazy. If you’ve put enough effort into it, a moustache and suit together with your demeanor should do the job. People of colour don’t go around painting themselves shades lighter when they go to costume parties dressed as white characters or people.

  2. Dan says

    No, the constant fixation on race is what is racist and wrong. We talk about inclusion, and diversity, but when it’s practiced it’s ‘racism’ and ‘cultural appropriation’.

    It’s part of the white guilt Kafka-trap the Sociology and gender study departments have laid out to perpetuate a system where only straight white men can be sexist or racist by the definition which they teach, and who it’s impossible to be racist or sexist toward.

    The claim is always ‘white supremacist patriarchy’ and yet anything which offend a ‘minority’ leads to mass castigation and often legal punishment, firing or expulsion.

    We’re at the point where women are 60% of college students, and yet are considered a disadvantaged minority. it’s ludicrous, and so is this hyper-vigilance of race issues.

  3. Ahmed says

    Not wrong. If painting blackface is wrong them being black in general is wrong. I am not responsible for the history of people before me. Also this is simply insecurities from people talking here. Just because someone paints themselfs black doesn’t mean they have an trying against black people. To determine that you need much more then their sense of humor. Also racist jokes are also not wrong, they point out the fact that racism exist and at times is very absurd. So this could very well be turned to the other side: blackface is good because the existence of it shows that people don’t get offended by what color you are before you made a joke or chose to dress as a black character.

  4. […] said “the filter is a form of blackface, cultural appropriation, and totally problematic. As we’ve written before, blackface is nothing other than a form of dress-up. It is offensive. This is a caricature of a […]

Leave A Reply

Your email address will not be published.