Springbok transformation: “This is just not the right time to question such issues”

Little-known political party, the Agency for New Agenda (ANA) has launched a legal bid to prevent the Springboks from competing in the Rugby World Cup later this month, saying the team does not represent the majority of South Africans. LIZEKA MADUNA asked Durbanites what they make of the move.

HaileHaile Pimenta, 26, student, Durban North
Sport is one of those things which is meant to break all kind of barriers or perceptions that people have instilled in their heads, be it sex or race. I think that people need to understand that, yes, diversity is important but it is not always the case. For instance, we can’t have people selected to represent our nation because of their skin colour. It’s whether one has got skills and are good at what they do, or not. Not everything is about race; it is irrelevant to try and prevent the national team to go and represent the country in London.

MbaliMbali Mngomezulu, 21, student, St George’s
This is not the first [rugby] world cup, it’s actually the third, hence I don’t really get the point of questioning transformation now. Yes, there are brilliant rugby players of colour but we have to admit that talent begins at a primary level and in most black schools there is no rugby. Therefore, one cannot really say they want to start playing rugby when they are out of school. When it comes to sport, it is not really about race, but it is more about skills. Similarly, our soccer national team is more dominated with black guys than any other race but I doubt that has been questioned because blacks are undoubtedly good in soccer. I find it ambiguous that South Africa would want to compromise great talent for race.

BonganiBongani Gema, 23, student, Durban Central
Since the country became a democratic state, transformation in South African sport has been on our lips but this is not the perfect time to question the matter of transformation. This is the World Cup and a very special moment for us as the nation. We cannot cripple a great team because of the questions that only get asked when it’s time for big events such as the World Cup. I don’t think black rugby players are being given a chance to prove themselves but it is not the matter of race; in most black schools and townships, rugby as a sport isn’t that common. This means that these guys aren’t catered for. The fact that transformation is important cannot be stressed enough but it can’t be questioned at this moment.

sthandwaSthandwa Gwala, 23, student, Glenwood
Generally talent and skills aren’t about one’s race; we cannot be associating every little thing with race. I don’t believe that black rugby players are being given a chance to prove themselves when it comes to rugby but I also think that might be because they don’t really show interest. Transformation within the rugby sector can be implemented but measures don’t have to be taken at the very moment where the team has to be getting ready for the World Cup. If we as South Africans decide to question the matter of transformation in sport, I guess we should begin with soccer that is more dominated with black guys more than any other races.

GraemeGraeme Johnson, 51, worker, Sydenham
There is transformation [in rugby] but it is quite slow, which makes it questionable. Players of colour aren’t really given a chance to prove themselves, this could be because the coach is old-school from the 1995 team. We should be concerned about transformation within rugby in this country but this is just not the right time to question such issues. There is a perception that rugby is a white sport. But that is not the case, it is just a mentality that we as people have since we are not being given a chance to prove that we do have talent and required skills to make it to the top. But preventing the team from going to London is absurd and I don’t see it as possible.

– Voxes have been edited for brevity and clarity
– Featured image via  Prozonesports.com, all other images by Lizeka Maduna 

You might also like More from author

3 Comments

  1. Nadine says

    Its good to see that most of the comments have been sensible- this agency for a new agenda sounds like a dumb org and Im glad people are able to look beyond race!

  2. solinus jolliffe says

    Disclaimer first. I love rugby, played it in private school as a student. I also love South Africa. I’d like to see two national teams, one black and one white (or mixed according to merit if they so wish). Let them compete regularly throughout the season to determine who best represents SA and plays in international competitions. Enough with the racism and transformation pressures which dull one’s spirit. Competition so much better than anger and resentment.

Leave A Reply

Your email address will not be published.