Benjamin Netanyahu and the speech that didn’t exist

A Palestinian flag flies at a pro-Palestinian rally in Gauteng. Photo by Ihsaan Haffejee

A racist speech attributed to Israeli Prime
 Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has caused outrage among South Africans. But what if the speech never existed? RA’EESA PATHER reports.

SOUTH AFRICANS PROTEST FOR GAZA IH 8

In Gaza, violence is escalating. But you’ve probably heard about that. Israel has partnered up with Egypt to announce a ceasefire, but they forgot to tell Hamas about it.

In the past few days, Palestinian and Israeli supporters have been buzzing across social media. Statistics, news articles and images of bloodied children have been widely shared. But how much of it is 
truthful?

Recently, a racist speech accredited to Israeli Prime
 Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has had South Africans spluttering with 
rage.

“The State of Israel that we know of today has not been created by 
wishful thinking… We do not pretend like other whites that we like the 
blacks. The fact that, blacks and Arabs look like human beings and act 
like human beings do not necessarily make them sensible human beings.”
excerpt from a speech attributed to Netanyahu.

But what if that speech never existed?

The speech was sent around Facebook, WhatsApp and via email. The intention was to inform as many people as possible that this is the real Netanyahu – a racist leader who believes that as far human beings go, well, Arabs and blacks aren’t really all that. The message went viral in Muslim networks, and is said to have been shared by Affan Sosibo of the African National Congress Youth League.

It’s easy to understand why these words would have South Africans 
dizzy with fury. After all, we are still recovering from our own
 history. 

The speech paints Israelis as the superior race, while Arabs and
 blacks are slighted as the lowest of humans. Through its religious
 preaching that “a Jew is [an] honest, God fearing person, who has demonstrated practically the right way of being” it tugs at colonial
 justification as to why colonisation is necessary. It’s what God 
wanted, right?

But it was a hoax, and right now the online world is saying that this
 speech actually belongs to former South African apartheid president PW
Botha.

“The Republic of South Africa that we know of today has not been 
created by wishful thinking… We do not pretend like other Whites that
we like Blacks. The fact that, Blacks look like human beings and act
like human beings do not necessarily make them sensible human beings”.
excerpt from the speech which is now attributed to PW Botha.

Netanyahu’s and Botha’s speeches are almost identical. The difference,
of course, is that Netanyahu’s speech refers to Arabs. In 
a remarkable play, it would seem the speech of a former apartheid 
leader has been manipulated into the words of a current apartheid 
leader. Almost disturbingly poetic.

Yet, if you dig into Botha’s speech and try to search for any
 conclusive evidence that he ever made it, you will find nothing. The
 speech is a hoax. It never existed. In fact, you could find the real version of the
 speech here.

The address is alleged to be a reprint that was published in the
 Sunday Times, but the Sunday Times has called the speech “utterly 
fictitious“.

There have been several instances where images have been re-appropriated from other contexts and used as fodder to mobilise Palestinian support. For example, a photograph of a child kneeling execution-style with guns circling his head, has been widely shared on Twitter. #PrayforGaza is the caption, but the correct caption is actually #PrayforSyria: this photo is not from Palestine, it was taken in Syria. It is unjustifiable to take the violence and persecution from one nation and use it to gather support for another.

But the digital world is full of mischief.

 Yes, search engines like Google and websites like Snopes make it easier to uncover hoaxes. But online users 
are humans, and humans can get it wrong. A simple share can be read by 
hundreds, creating a viral wave of misinformed people. As 
such, the resistance itself becomes manipulated and misinformed. So
 why are these hoaxes so easily believed? Are we too lazy to inform
 ourselves, simply clutching onto whatever information we see?

The Palestinian people have been living under oppression for more than 60 years. It
 is the longest-lasting colonial tyranny in the modern era. Yes, there 
is a need to encourage further resistance, to inform more people about 
the mounting atrocities. But by spreading falsehoods, we are 
doing the Palestinian people an injustice. We are fooling and
 manipulating people into believing the struggle is justified, and how 
does that make us better than the oppressors we denounce?

We owe the Palestinian people more than that. We owe them 
a true fight.

You might also like More from author

8 Comments

  1. Mohammad says

    Morons. Israel is awful enough without this silliness. However, former interior minister Eli Yishai did say this recently about African refugees:

    “Most of those people arriving here are Muslims who think the country doesn’t belong to us, the white man,” Yishai said in the interview with Maariv.

    http://mondoweiss.net/2012/06/israeli-interior-minister-on-african-immigrants-most-of-those-people-arriving-here-are-muslims-who-think-the-country-doesnt-belong-to-us-the-white-man.html

    1. Larry Butchins says

      Eli Yishai is an idiot and does not reflect the general attitude of Israelis. Israel is the only country in the region that actually opened its gates to African refugees, while they were being shot to death in Egypt, Israel took them in. There are now 50,000 Black African refugees in Israel, and while I personally believe we could do a lot more for them and do not agree with the expulsions and repatriation – particularly to despotic regimes where they might face imprisonment or death – we treat them far better than the US does of refugees from Mexico.

  2. Sue says

    Thanks for posting this. Your site is an oasis of balance and credibility, and articles like this go a long way towards making people think before they add to the noise and chaos on social media.

  3. Lorraine Zive says

    How disgusting, why???????? Do people cause more heartache than it is neccessay. There will never be peace if ficticious reports carry on this way.

    1. Mduduzi says

      @ Diana Sullivan, well said.
      Judaism is not about race (a fictitious concept in itself) but culture and religion.
      This hoax is resurfacing to try discredit Trump-Brexit-Israel-Syria-Russia realignment against sponsored terrorism.

Leave A Reply

Your email address will not be published.