Citizen. Speak. Amplify.

#ValhallaMosque: When white supremacy is threatened by prayer

The conflict over the construction of the Valhalla Mosque in Pretoria is more than just an isolated display of religious intolerance. It speaks of race dynamics far more complex than that, argues AAISHA DADI PATEL.

Fears of creeping Islamophobia have taken over in Pretoria’s suburb of Valhalla, where angry (mostly white) residents have come out against the construction of a mosque and community centre. A protest was staged, and people’s inner Penny Sparrows came out as they spewed bigotry online, opposing the construction.

But this protest action is more than just about Muslims needing to reassure the broader community that Islam is a peaceful religion. What this is actually doing is revealing the way in which white supremacy still has prevalence in South Africa, and still makes a public appearances.

This is, of course, no massive surprise. But Islamophobia in a South African context is a concept that deserves some examination.

Twenty two years or so into democracy, we’re seeing the ways that the Rainbow Nation narrative is a massive whitewash. We’re calling it out for pushing ideas of equality and fairness when the reality is far from that. And while Muslims may have access to halaal food and (for the most part) are able to wear headscarves without harassment, they still do face creeping Islamophobia. It’s the man yelling at you that you can’t park in a certain place, or the angry drove of protesters telling you not to build a mosque in their area because the noise will disturb their animals.

The issue with the dissent against the construction of a mosque – a place of prayer – is that a majority-white community is telling people that they can’t be on their land, and they’re trying to use principles of anti-racism to justify it. It’s like they’ve completely forgotten about this thing called colonialism, or how they got to Africa in the first place.

Islamophobia in post-apartheid South Africa is arguably rooted in two things: the conflation of race and religion (“Islam is a brown person’s religion”), and global terrorism narratives.

Through statements such as “Paris, Brussels, Valhalla???” and “Geen ISIS in Valhalla” (“no ISIS in Valhalla”) it’s clear that the community is scared of an imminent ISIS invasion or Boko Haram bombing, buying into global narratives a la Fox News of Islam being an extremist and dangerous religion.

Through statements like “Indian neighbours YES. Muslim invasion NO”, protesters are trying to make it appear that they are totally tolerant. They love samoosas and Indian people, so they’re definitely not racist – but Islam is dangerous so they need to be cautious. They are quick to point out that they are not racist when ironically, their bigotry stems from conflating religion and race.

They will deny that they are racist, shifting the focus onto an inconsequential thing such as the call to prayer. What this does is imply ignorance about religion, but ignorance implies innocence. And they’re not innocent – the fact remains that these individuals are racist and do not want anything that may threaten their white supremacist ideals.

A 2014 report claims that there are around 150 Muslim families in Valhalla, and they currently gather to pray in congregation in each other’s homes. There is a community of around 8, 000 in the area – not all of whom are Christian – and there are six churches.

But again, the issue is not about freedom of religion. It’s about upholding white supremacy.

And this is something that the Democratic Alliance doesn’t seem to get. They released a statement claiming that they were in full support of the construction of the mosque from the start, as they are fully in support of freedom of religion. Ironic when in 2013, DA councillor Ina Strijdom said that she was neutral on the matter.

While the mosque has been given the go-ahead and the mayor of Tshwane, Kgosiento Ramokgopa has pledged his full support for it, it’s highly likely that the community will continue to protest. Freedom Front Plus member in the area Anel Geyser has tried to justify dissent against the mosque by claiming that it is not the fact that Muslims are coming to live in the area that people are angry about – it is the “blaring” noise of the mosque in their “quiet and peaceful” neighbourhood. This is the classic colonial narrative: assuming that only whiteness can maintain peacefulness and respect, and that allowing any outsiders into that space will disrupt that.

Apartheid certainly connived to situate race and class in our society so deeply that it will take years – decades even – for us to decipher the impacts completely. Perhaps it is only through the disruption of whiteness that we’ll actually be able to move on and deal with the psychological scars of apartheid.

But it’s not your time to play victim, whiteness. Don’t worry though – I will pray for you.

Featured image via Flickr


  1. Jason says

    Racism is very much alive in good old South Africa.

    Richard Botha failed to provide a single justifiable reason as to why the mosque is opposed.

    What’s more, he failed miserably at trying to hide his blatant and obvious racism and supremacy.

  2. Jon Low says

    They object to the public noise of the daily call-to-prayer muezzin, probably? It’s far less melodious than the ringing of church-bells only on Sundays.

  3. Nick says

    Why build a mosque in a predominantly non Muslim area anyway?can I come and build a mega church in a Muslim area?

    1. Rabia says

      It will serve the needs of the Muslims that do live in the area. Unlike Christians, Muslims pray 5 times a day and the reward is far greater if performed in congregation in a mosque. Hope this answers your question.

    2. Don says

      how do you quantify predominantly a muslim, christian area, South Africa is a multicultural country.

    3. Aboo Hassim says

      @Nick I live in a predominantly Muslim area with a recently built mega church – and there has been no hate surrounding it.

    4. Nazo says

      U welcome to build ur church , doesn’t really matter cos ur churches are empty most of the time.

  4. Rabia says

    And Nick, there are no Muslim /Non muslim areas. That is the whole problem with that type of mentality. Anybody can live wherever they wish in South Africa. Muslims, non muslims, black, whites, Indians, coloreds are all neighbours. Segregation is supposed to have died when apartheid was demolished but obviously it is still alive

    1. Indian white says

      Very convenient for some muslims to take advantage of other secular countries when their own countries dont give the same right to non muslims.and for the dumb patel over here who is trying to gain sympathy for herself by making it a white vs brown issue-you got to stop complaining girl and stop trying to score some brownie points for yourself.

      1. guy says

        Iran does…. so enough stereotyping from you too…….

    2. guy says

      Even in Boksburg? Now i wanna see a mosque and Zulu kraal in Boksburg LOL

  5. Farhaad says

    If the “blaring” noise of the mosque in their “quiet and peaceful” neighbourhood is the real reason for opposing the mosque than the residents of Valhalla need not worry depending on the area and bylaws mosques do not always have a loud call to prayer. Eg the Houghton mosques broadcast the athaan on a short range radio station.
    There are over 250 muslim families in Valhalla currently and growing, so yes there is a need.
    Makes you wonder what is the true motive behind opposing the construction of the mosque.
    And yes a church/temple/synagogue can be build in a so called predominantly “muslim area” and there will be no objection.

  6. Nazeem Babulal says

    Note how that whenever a mosque is to be constructed, we have to justify the need for the mosque, compromise on the adhaan, make provisions for parking (this one is justified). Refer to same in Queensburgh (Durban), Musgrave (Durban). How do these nay sayers protest when taxis drive by at any time of day with music blaring, youngsters over revving their engines, etc. Shame these appear to be pre dominantly DA areas…..

    1. guy says

      Well, this all but GUARANTEED my vote for the ANC, corruption and all, the ANC gives muslims more rights than even muslims do in their own countries

Leave A Reply

Your email address will not be published.