Citizen. Speak. Amplify.

Young people have mixed sentiments about the #CabinetReshuffle

Sabeehah Motala (22), a student and intern at Corruption Watch, was at a dinner party on Thursday evening when her work WhatsApp group lit up with the news of the cabinet reshuffle. Motala turned on the TV and watched in horror.

Last week, President Jacob Zuma finally made the dreaded cabinet reshuffle that had been expected since he called then-Finance Minister Pravin Gordhan back from an investors’ roadshow in the UK.  Zuma fired five ministers, including Gordhan, and moved several more to other departments, sending the country into a tailspin.

The reshuffle came just a day after former Robben Island inmate and African National Congress (ANC) struggle hero Ahmed Kathrada was buried. Since then, South Africans have been lamenting the state of nation – the rand is sinking, the country has been downgraded to junk status and mass action is being organised demanding that Zuma step down.

“What scares me is that our president is able to ruthlessly, audaciously and arrogantly abuse his power, as if daring the people to take a stand. Zuma is too comfortable in his position, he feels untouchable,” Motala told The Daily Vox.

Tshegofatso Putu (21), who studies politics, philosophy and economics, is also afraid of the absolute power Zuma seems to have in the ANC. “He is untouchable in the ANC and continues to ensure that he surrounds himself with people he wields influence over. This reshuffle … is self-serving. I do not believe that [it] is based on merit, but to ensure the longevity of Zuma’s power and influence until the end of his tenure,” she said.

Mxolisi Masango (23), a law student, had been listening to the radio, waiting for news of the cabinet reshuffle. He said he’d been expecting a reshuffle ever since 2015 when then-finance minister Nhlanhla Nene was fired and replaced by ANC loyalist, Des van Rooyen.

Masango said he’s despondent about the reshuffle because this means more division in the ANC. “There will be easy access to capital and they [Zuma’s faction] can do whatever they want with taxpayers’ money. There will be looting and the party taking over in 2019 will have nothing to inherit.”

Motala is also concerned about the negative economic impact the reshuffle will have on people whose salaries won’t change, but who will still have to fork out extra money for a loaf of bread.  “The value of the rand dropping means that things are going to be more expensive,” she said.

Bongeka Makatsa (24), an entrepreneur, is also troubled by the weakening rand. “Less FDI [foreign direct investment] could destabilise the businesses that heavily rely on it. When that happens, I as an entrepreneur suffer because it means less disposable income for my customers,” she said.

For energy and climate change consultant, Kukhanya Ncube (26), the biggest concern is the nuclear deal. Government’s plans to develop a 9.6GW nuclear production facility is shrouded in controversy over links between the Russian nuclear industry, the wealthy Gupta family and certain factions of the ANC. Both Gordhan and Nene opposed the deal. “[I’m afraid] that the nuclear deal will now go ahead,” said Ncube, who said he was afraid that “the Guptas now have their hands on the treasury”.

The Zuma and Gupta alliance, referred to by some as the “Zuptas”, is considered by many to be guilty of state capture – high level of corruption where an outside party has a hand in high-impact governmental decisions.

Putu said Zuma’s rearranging of the cabinet will have tangible repercussions on the lives of many. “I’m tired of complaining about Zuma. He has survived every controversy – from his rape case to Nkandla and GuptaGate. The ANC has shown itself to be morally corrupt and have made him untouchable to their own detriment.”

Putu refuses to be a part of what she called “white-liberal initiated action” like #ZumaMustFall and #BlackMonday.  These groups, she said, only rally when there is a threat to the stability white capital needs to continue thriving, she said, and never for the issues that face black South Africans.

Instead, she would be making her voice heard in the 2019 election. “We need a government that is not morally corrupt and irreproachable,” she said.

Masango also opposed protesting the reshuffle. “Zuma has the right to fire ministers and appoint [them]. I can’t protest against a president that was elected democratically. The ANC themselves need to remove him.”

Although he is unhappy with the direction the country is going, party politics dictate that it is the ANC’s duty – and not the public’s – to remove Zuma, he said.

“Our problems go beyond Zuma. I advocate for radical economic transformation and I think that’s what Zuma is trying to push. He is not the perfect person to push that agenda, his reputation is tarnished and we can no longer trust him. South Africa faces a very bleak and dark future,” he said.

But some are not content with waiting for the general election. On Monday, several groups called for Zuma to resign and are pushing for public protests.

Motala she plans to demonstrate. “I don’t want to watch more of my country being sold off to the Zupta franchise,” she said, adding, “I think people have forgotten what democratic participation means. It doesn’t just end after you cast your ballot.”

She’s optimistic about the country’s future. “We just need people to remember that this country belongs to us. It’s a tough battle but as long as there are people with the energy for change, I can’t and won’t stop fighting to fix it,” she said.

Ncube is also prepared to protest. He said South Africans have a responsibility to “hold uBaba accountable. We have a great potential as a growing economy, but we have put our future in the wrong hands. It is now every citizen’s duty to save the state from looters, or else the future generations will inherit a broken, indebted South Africa.”

But Makatsa doesn’t see the point in protesting when what’s needed is “clear systematic change”. “People have been trying [to get Zuma to step down] and all it equals to at the end of the day is a fun day in the sun where Zuma’s enemies feed you KFC,” she said.

Still, she isn’t worried about the frenzy over the cabinet reshuffle. “We don’t have to start planning to leave for Australia just yet, my people. South Africa will be fine.”

Featured image via Twitter
3 Comments
  1. Garbly says

    George Soros funds your website through the Open Society Foundation. Every article is intended to race-bait. At least your fulfilling your mandate.

  2. Concerned says

    I’m happy to see the above views. Ten years ago, there was not nearly such a level of involvement. South Africa is a majority black country and as such must be driven by black consciousness. The above comments show we are moving in the right direction.

    Unfortunately the sheer power the President wields in the ANC is now very obvious. Whether action protects white capital or some other marginal-yet-overwhelming sector of society is, for the time being, irrelevant. The greater danger is an executive that is now poised to do serious structural damage to the country’s institutions. Recovering finances is easy, fixing institutions is much harder.

    TBH, I don’t think protests will help, nor will the 2019 elections. The President has two years to fully consolidate his power and the ANC MPs resigning is giving him that gap. Given how effectively he has played the game so far, two years is more than enough time. He will have purged most of his opponents by the end of this year. Waiting for the poor and disenfranchised to rise is equally pointless. They have been rising, to the tune of 1,000 service delivery protests a month. The state simply ignores them.

    Let us not underestimate the ability of the President to truly take full control. Just as he has used the in-fighting of the ANC to strengthen his position, he will use our own arguments over what to do as the same lever. White capital and black consciousness won’t mean a hoot if we have to live under an autocracy.

  3. ross says

    You have elected a member of parliament to represent you, this person has failed to do so, if Zuma says to his dog, the dog sits, if he says roll over the dog rolls over, that is who you elected to parliament, so it is not only a matter of what Zuma does or does not, it is a matter of how he has corrupted parliament, that is how he has corrupted your vote!

Leave A Reply

Your email address will not be published.